Best Rated Toaster Ovens

Great Toaster Ovens At Affordable Prices

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach 31511 Toaster Oven Pro
Hamilton Beach 31511 Toaster Oven Pro

The best rated toaster ovens will provide consumers with great selections of non-convection toaster ovens. There are two basic types of toaster ovens convection, and non-convection. The differences are how these ovens cook food. They are very affordable and will not break the budget.

Convection ovens have fans in them that make foods cook faster and more evenly. Non-convection toasters heat unevenly since the heating elements are just inches away from the food. They are more versatile than non-convection ones.

Non-convection toaster ovens are less expensive than convection models. They may also have slightly less features and options. All these models allow you to bake, broil and toast. Others, add additional features like bagel, warm, defrost, or roast.

Toaster ovens are great because they use less electricity and cook foods faster than the conventional oven. They are small enough to fit into small area and light enough to move around.

Top Rated Non-Convection Toaster Ovens

Check out these top rated toaster ovens.

#1. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach 31127D Easy Reach Toaster Oven Pro
Hamilton Beach 31127D Easy Reach Toaster Oven Pro

Model: 31127D ASIN: B06WGNC8Q4 Ratings: 872 Overall Score: 4.5

Awards: Amazon’s Choice

This model toaster oven comes with 1400 watts and 0.36 cubic feet capacity. Easy to read dials and roll-top door makes food easy to reach as the door opens above the oven. It also has optional stay-one setting, slice out crumb tray, power indicator light, interior light, adjustable rack, and automatic shut off. You can bake, broil, toast and warm food. There is enough room to fit a 9 x 11 baking pan and a 12 inch pizza.

PROS

  • Fits a 9 x 11 inch baking pan
  • Fits a 12 inch pizza
  • Roll out top door
  • Door opens above the oven
  • Removable crumb tray
  • Optional stay-on setting
  • 6 slice toast capacity

CONS

  • Price
  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Hamilton Beach
  • Weight:4 lbs.
  • Color: Gray
  • Dimensions:41” H x 18.74” W x 15.24” D
  • Interior Dimensions:8” H x 12.5” W x 10.5” D
  • Cord Length: 24 inches
  • Material Type: Steel
  • Number of Slices: 6
  • Cooking Modes: Bake, Broil, Toast, & Warm
  • Features: Slide out crumb tray, Timer, Power Indicator Light, Adjustable Rack, Automatic Shut Off
  • Capacity:36 cubic feet
  • Watts: 1400
  • Warranty: 1-year

#2. Breville The Compact Smart Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Breville BOV650XL Compact Smart Oven
Breville BOV650XL Compact Smart Oven

Model: BOV650XL ASIN: B00357YS3A Ratings: 219 Overall Score: 4.5

Awards: Amazon’s Choice

This model toaster over has 1800 watts and a 0.6 cubic feet capacity. You can bake, broil, toast and roast. It has an LED display, non-stick interior, tempered glass door, and a frozen foods defrost button.

PROS

  • 6 cubic feet capacity
  • 5 cooking modes
  • LED display
  • Non-stick interior for easy cleaning
  • Timer and alarm
  • Power indicator light
  • Interior lighting
  • Pull out crumb tray

CONS

  • Price
  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Breville
  • Weight:9 lbs.
  • Color: Silver
  • Dimensions:25” H x 16.5” W x 15.5” D
  • Interior Dimensions:25” H x 11.75” W x 10” D
  • Material Type: Steel
  • Number of Slices: 4
  • Capacity:6 cubic feet
  • Features: Slide-out crumb tray, Timer, Alarm, Power Indicator Light, Interior Light, Adjustable Rack
  • Cooking Modes: 5 (Bake, Broil, Roast, Toast, Warm)
  • In the Box: Oven, broiling and baking pans, warranty and instructions
  • Commercial or Residential Certifications: Yes
  • Warranty: 1-year

#3. Breville The Mini Smart Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven
Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven

Model: BOV450XL ASIN: B006CVVA7I Ratings: 2,514 Overall Score: 4.4

This top rated model has 1800 watts of power and comes with eight preset cooking functions. It also includes a defrost button, slide-out crumb tray, LED display, and automatic shut-off.

PROS

  • 8 Cooking modes (Bagel, Bake, Broil, Cookies, Pizza, Roast, Toast, & Reheat)
  • Defrost function
  • Temperature conversion from Fahrenheit to Celsius
  • Slide-out crumb tray
  • Power indicator light
  • Automatic shut off
  • Body is sturdy and durable

CONS

  • Price
  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Breville
  • Weight:2 lbs.
  • Color: Silver
  • Dimensions:75” H x 16” W x 14.25” D
  • Cord Length: 3 feet
  • Watts: 1800
  • Material Type: Steel
  • Features: Slide-out crumb tray, timer, alarm, power indictor light, interior light, adjustable rack, and automatic shut-off
  • Number of Slices: 4
  • Capacity:45 cubic feet
  • Timer Max Setting: 120 minutes
  • Commercial or Residential Certifications: Yes
  • Warranty: 1-year

#4. Cuisinart Toaster Oven Broiler

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Cuisinart TOB-1010 Toaster Oven
Cuisinart TOB-1010 Toaster Oven

Model: TOB-1010 ASIN: B07F1LKR61 Ratings: 393 Overall Score: 4.3

This affordable brand has 1800 watts of power and 0.5 cubic feet capacity that’s enough to fit 6 slices. It has an auto slide out rack to remove food easily. It also has a non-stick interior, slide out crumb tray, and can bake an 11 inch pizza.

PROS

  • 5 cubic feet capacity
  • 1800 watts
  • Cool to the touch exterior
  • Non-stick interior for easy cleaning
  • Slide-out crumb tray
  • Power indicator light
  • Auto slide-out rack to easily remove food

CONS

  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Cuisinart
  • Weight:9 lbs.
  • Color: Stainless Steel
  • Dimensions:75” H x 17.125” W x 19.375” D
  • Capacity:5 cubic feet
  • Cord Length: 20 inches
  • Number of Slices: 6
  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Automatic Shut Off: No
  • Cooking Modes: Bake, Broil, Pizza, Toast & Warm
  • Features: Cool touch exterior, slide-out crumb tray, alarm, power indicator light
  • Warranty: 3-years

#5. Proctor Silex Toaster Oven 

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Proctor Silex 31122 Toaster Oven
Proctor Silex 31122 Toaster Oven

Model: 31122 ASIN: B01JOZSER2 Ratings: 343 Overall Score: 4.3

This toaster oven has 1100 watts of power and room to toast up to 4 slices of bread. It has 3 knob controls, 30 minute timer, and three cooking modes; bake, broil, and toast. Large enough to fit a 9 inch pizza. You can also adjust the temperature from 150ºF-450ºF.

PROS

  • 3 Knob controls
  • 30 Minute timer
  • Temperature control
  • Fits a 9-inch pizza
  • Automatic shutoff
  • Bake pan included
  • 3 Cooking functions (bake, broil, & toast)
  • Lightweight and easy to move around

CONS

  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Hamilton Beach
  • Weight:71 lbs.
  • Color: Black/Silver
  • Dimensions:25” H x 14.75” W x 11.5” D
  • Cord Length: 24 inches
  • Drop Down Crumb Tray: Yes
  • Temperature Control: 150ºF-450ºF
  • Warranty: 1-year

#6. Hamilton Beach 4 Slice Toaster Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach 31401 Toaster Oven Pro
Hamilton Beach 31401 Toaster Oven Pro

Model: 31401 ASIN: B015YUDYVM Ratings: 1,096 Overall Score: 4.2

Awards: Amazon’s Choice

This affordable Hamilton Beach toaster oven has 1100 watts of power, 0.45 cubic feet capacity, and 3 cooking modes. It has a 30 minutes timer and auto shutoff. The temperature is adjustable, uses 75% less electricity than a typical oven, non-slip feet and an easy removable crumb tray.

PROS

  • Room to fit a 9 inch pizza
  • 30 minute timer
  • Automatic shutoff
  • Adjustable temperature
  • Non-slip feet
  • Uses 75% less energy and cooks 28% faster than a typical oven

CONS

  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Hamilton Beach
  • Weight:33 lbs.
  • Color: Stainless Steel
  • Dimensions:7” H x 14.96” W x 11.5” D
  • Interior Dimensions: 7” H x 10.5” W x 10” D
  • Cord length: 27 inches
  • Number of Slices: 4
  • Material: Stainless Steel
  • Capacity:45 cubic feet
  • Watts: 1100
  • Toaster Oven Features: Slide-out crumb tray, timer, alarm, power indicator light, adjustable rack, & auto shutoff
  • Cooking Modes: 3 (Bake, Broil, Toast)
  • Warranty: 1-year

#7. Hamilton Beach 6 Slice Toaster Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach 31508 Toaster Oven Pro
Hamilton Beach 31508 Toaster Oven Pro

Model: 31508 ASIN: B001QYKWOI Ratings: 185 Overall Score: 4.1

This 6 slice toaster oven has 1300 watts with a 0.48 cubic feet capacity. You can bake, broil and toast up to 6 slices with this unit. It has a stay-on setting and a 15 minute timer with auto shutoff.

PROS

  • 1300 watts
  • Stay on setting
  • 15 minute timer with auto shutoff
  • Bake, broil, and toast settings
  • Slide-out crumb tray for easy cleanup
  • Cook up to 6 slices of bread

CONS

  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Hamilton Beach
  • Weight: 14 lbs.
  • Color: Black
  • Dimensions:94” H x 16.81” W x 13.03” D
  • Interior Dimensions: 7” H x 11” W x 10” D
  • Material: Steel
  • Capacity:48 cubic feet
  • Number of Slices: 6
  • Cooking Modes: 3 (Bake, Broil, Toast)
  • Oven Features: Slide-out crumb tray, Timer, Alarm, Automatic shutoff
  • Timer: Yes, max setting 30 minutes

#8. Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven 31511

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Hamilton Beach 31511 Toaster Oven Pro
Hamilton Beach 31511 Toaster Oven Pro

Model: 31511 ASIN: B005QB4ULS Ratings: 604 Overall Score: 4.1

This 1300 watt oven has a thirty minute timer with an automatic shutoff. You can bake, broil and toast. It comes with a bake pan and broil rack. It also has a removable crumb tray, time, alarm, fits a 9” pizza, and has a power indicator light. It is made of stainless steel and comes with a 1-year warranty.

PROS

  • Slide-out crumb tray
  • 3 Cooking modes (Bake, Broil, & Toast)
  • 30 minute timer with auto shutoff
  • Lightweight and easy to move around
  • Toasts 6 slices of bread
  • Power indicator light

CONS

  • No interior light
  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Hamilton Beach
  • Weight:48 lbs.
  • Color: Stainless Steel
  • Cord Length: 24 inches
  • Dimensions:94” H x 16.81” W x 13.03” D
  • Internal Dimensions: 7” H x 11” W x 10” D
  • Watts: 1300
  • Material Type: Stainless Steel
  • Timer: 30 minutes max setting
  • Oven Features: Slide-out crumb tray, timer, alarm, power indicator light, adjustable rack, and auto shutoff
  • Number of Slices: 6
  • Capacity:48 cubic feet
  • Warranty: 1-year

#9. Continental Electric Toaster Oven

 

Best Rated Toaster Ovens - Continental Electric Toaster Oven Pro
Continental Electric Toaster Oven Pro

Model: CE-TO101 ASIN: B07DBCYB2H Ratings: 23 Overall Score: 4.0

Awards: Amazon’s Choice

This model toaster oven has 1000 watts of power that has a 60 minute timer that holds up to 4 slices of bread. A baking pan and pull out rack are included. You can bake, broil, toast and warm with this oven. It’s lightweight so it’s easy to move around. Comes with a 2-year warranty.

PROS

  • Pilot light
  • Adjustable temperature levels
  • Slide-out crumb tray for easy cleaning
  • 60 minute timer
  • Stay on function
  • Baking pan and rack included and dishwasher safe
  • Great for small areas like apartments or college dorms

CONS

  • Made in China

OTHER KEY FACTS

  • Brand: Continental Electric
  • Weight:95 lbs.
  • Color: White
  • Cord Length: 25 inches
  • Material: Steel
  • Dimensions:5” H x 10” W x 9” D
  • Interior Dimensions:5” H x 9” W x 8.5” D
  • Oven Features: Slide-out crumb tray, Timer, Alarm, Power indicator light, Adjustable rack, Automatic shutoff
  • Cooking Modes: 4 (Bake, Broil, Toast, & Warm)
  • Timer: 60 minutes max setting
  • Warranty: 2-years limited

Conclusion

There are some great selections in this list of toaster ovens. If you have a limited budget, you should find one that fits very nicely. Each of these models have the same cooking modes, while other may have some additional ones you may be interested in. They are all lightweight and will be easy to move around from place to place.

Shop Toaster Ovens

Below are the top 9 models listed for your choice. Just click on an image of interest where you will be taken to Amazon to place the order. While there, you can read the customer reviews and frequently asked questions.

 

#1. Hamilton Beach 31127D

Check Current Price On Amazon

Hamilton Beach 6-Slice 31127D Toaster Oven

#2. Breville BOV650XL

Check Current Price On Amazon

Breville BOV650XL Toaster Oven

#3. Breville BOV450XL

Check Current Price On Amazon

Breville BOV450XL Mimi Smart Toaster Oven

#4. Cuisinart TOB-1010

Check Current Price On Amazon

Cuisinart TOB-1010 Toaster Broiler Oven

#5. Proctor Silex 31122

Check Current Price On Amazon

Proctor Silex 31122 Toaster Oven

#6. Hamilton Beach 31401

Check Current Price On Amazon

Hamilton Beach 31401 Toaster Oven

#7. Hamilton Beach 31508

Check Current Price On Amazon

Hamilton Beach 31508 Toaster Oven

#8. Hamilton Beach 31511

Check Current Price On Amazon

Hamilton Beach 31511 Toaster Oven

#9. Continental Electric

Check Current Price On Amazon

Continental Electric CD-TO101 Toaster Oven